COMMISSION MEMBERS:
RIC WILLIAMSON, CHAIRMAN
HOPE ANDRADE
TED HOUGHTON, JR.
JOHN W. JOHNSON (not present)STAFF:
MICHAEL W. BEHRENS, P.E., Executive Director
STEVE SIMMONS, Deputy Executive Director
RICHARD MONROE, General Counsel
ROGER POLSON, Executive Assistant to the Deputy Executive Director
DEE HERNANDEZ, Chief Minute Clerk
PROCEEDINGS
MR. WILLIAMSON: Good morning. It is now
9:10 a.m. and I call the June 2005 meeting of the Texas Transportation
Commission to order. It is a pleasure to have all of you here this morning
and please note for the record that public notice of this meeting containing
all items on the agenda was filed with the office of the Secretary of State
at 1:33 p.m. on June 22, 2005.
Before we begin today's meeting, as we
always do, please take a moment to join with me and reaching into your
pocket or purse and pulling out your pager, your telephone, your dewberry
and whatever else you carry to remind you about life’s travails and put
those items on the silent or vibrate mode so that we might not be rudely
disrupted in our deliberations. Thank you very much.
This is a sad and joyous day. Normally we
would recognize each commissioner for remarks and see what their business,
but we have some special business to take care of and at this time I would
like to recognize Commissioner Nichols who will have a statement to enter
into the record.
Mr. NICHOLS: Good morning. Also I
appreciate all of you being here as the Commission does its business. I sent
a letter to Governor Perry this morning as well as copies to the Executive
Director Mike Behrens and the other commissioners and the department and I
think I’ll just read the letter and I think it will be self-explanatory.
"Dear Governor Perry, it is with great
regret but no hesitation that I resign my position with the Texas
Transportation Commission effective June 30 -- that’s today, at 8:00 a.m. It
has been one of my life’s greatest honors to have been appointed by both you
and former Governor George W. Bush to this position of responsibility that
impacts the daily lives of Texas citizens and businesses.
"It has been an honor to have been
confirmed twice by the Texas Senate and have served with six distinguished
commissioners. I have made clear my intention to announce for Texas Senate
District 3 if and when Senator Staples makes a formal announcement seeking
another office. While the Attorney General’s opinion indicates that I do not
need to resign until I file for a place in the Republican primary, I do not
consider it ethical or proper to vote on projects within that district, or
approve contracts, while seeking elective office.
"I’ll leave with the confidence and
knowledge that the department is in its best shape in decades. During the
past eight years, the department has tripled the number of roadway
construction projects being built each year; brought more local control and
input into the project programming and selection process, including funding
allocation; dramatically increased safety projects; approved the
establishment of five regional mobility authorities for the acceleration of
transportation projects under local control; accelerated reconstruction of
bridges both on and off the state system; funded and scheduled ninety
percent of highway projects planned for the next twelve years to be built in
half the time; established and accelerated construction of corridors
throughout the state on the Texas trunk system; passed historic rail
legislation and signed working agreements with major railroads for the
relocation and preservation of rail corridors; improved the overall physical
condition of the existing state system; given Texas voters a choice in
clearing traffic congestion by offering an historic constitutional amendment
resulting in the immediate construction of the 55-mile, 2.7 billion dollar
Central Texas system with more to come; begun implementation of the
Trans-Texas Corridor with the signing of the development agreement for the 6
billion dollar concession proposal paralleling I-35.
"Instead of costing taxpayers it will add
an additional 1.2 billion dollars to transportation along the corridor while
insuring property rights protections for landowners. Currently, a project is
underway, either large or small, every six miles on the Texas highway
system. Most importantly, without additional employees or raising fees or
taxes, the commission has increased production and safety to the benefit of
Texans.
"These accomplishments would have not been
possible without the policies, programs, new legislative tools with which
you have been instrumental. The administration, under the leadership of Mike
Behrens, is outstanding. The men and women running the divisions, districts
and other offices of TXDOT are intelligent, motivated and stable.
"The employees of the Texas Department of
Transportation are some of the most dedicated with which I have ever worked.
Their willingness to go the extra mile for the system of Texas is unmatched
and I will truly miss them. As I travel, I will never look at a highway or
road crew the same again. I thank you for the confidence you have shown me."
MR. WILLIAMSON: We’re going to have the
opportunity in a moment to continue to say our thanks to Robert. At this
time I need to recognize the fellow commission member on my immediate right,
or my far right, Ted Houghton. Ted.
MR. HOUGHTON: This is extremely
difficult for me. When I first came on to the commission, I looked for a
godfather and he sits right down to my left here, and he has served as a
great mentor to me, and yesterday was the first time that I sat in a
Trans-Texas Corridor negotiation meeting that Robert and I have been working
on over the last, what year, a little over a year, a year, and he wasn’t
there. And we had a room full of people, a conference call going on.
I said, Folks, there’s good news and bad
news about all this. The good news is I’m not the detail person and I do not
have the panache for detail like Commissioner Nichols does. But the bad news
is when he’s elected as your state -- as a state senator and he is in charge
of a committee of infrastructure and transportation, there'll be no BS-ing
this guy.
And I want to offer my congratulations and
I look forward to working with you in another capacity, Robert. Thank you
very much for your leadership.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Hope Andrade.
MS. ANDRADE: Commissioner, I think there
is a reason that somebody put a box of Kleenex here in front of me, but as I
told you earlier, thank you for everything that you have done for this
department. You certainly have left your mark here. And thank you for
everything that you did during my new year as a commissioner.
Everything that we see and we hear is
something that you either started or that you looked at or that you felt
that needed attention and you will be missed. And as I told you earlier, it
must be wonderful for you to feel the void that you are going to leave here
and that all your friends are missing you and that when you’re across the
street we’re going to look forward to going over there and asking for help.
But good luck, and I wish you the best and remember that you have a good
friend in San Antonio.
MR. WILLIAMSON: At this time I am going to
hold my remarks as I do for last. At this time I would like to recognize
Kris Heckmann personal representative of Governor Perry.
MR. HECKMANN: Good morning. I actually
think in the four years that I’ve been here this is the first time that I’ve
stood at this podium. So it’s very good, a good action. The Governor
couldn’t be here this morning. He’s traveling the state working on school
finance and such but he wrote a little note that he asked me to read you,
Robert.
It says "Dear Robert, as you resign your
post as Commissioner I would like to express my appreciation for your eight
years of service on the Texas Transportation Commission. Throughout your
tenure on the commission you have played a major role in the formation and
implementation of the most remarkable transportation policy in the nation.
"You embraced the job of commissioner like
few before you. Your intelligence, engaging personality and strong work
ethic are well known across our state. In the last eight years I think you
are the only person in Texas who has traveled more places, eaten more
chicken dinners and spoken to more people about state business than I have.
"I am grateful for your contributions as a
member of the commission and look forward to your next endeavor. Thank you
for your service to the Lone Star State. Sincerely, Rick Perry." Thanks.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Mr. Behrens, I think you
have something you need to say.
MR. BEHRENS: Yes, thank you Chairman. I’m
honored to read a resolution that was prepared for you commissioner and if
you’ll bear with me I’ll read this resolution. It says, "Whereas the Texas
Transportation Commission takes great pride in recognizing Robert Lee
Nichols for his vigor, good humor and insistent drive to ensure that Texas
be known for its excellence of its transportation systems. And, whereas Mr.
Nichols, often called the employees’ commissioner, wasted little time after
his appointment to learn about the department and to taste the bread. He
traveled the whole 25 districts listening to the men and women in the
trenches and through his genuine concern earned their respect by identifying
mosquitoes. And, whereas Mr. Nichols in the role of transportation
commissioner for eight years has provided creative insight, helpful guidance
and focused leadership in the development of policy in all operational areas
of the Texas Department of Transportation. And, whereas Mr. Nichols has
devoted his time and talents to public service with TXDOT since his initial
appointment by Governor George W. Bush to the Transportation Commission in
May, 1997, and his reappointment by Governor Rick Perry in June, 2003.
Whereas Mr. Nichols successfully worked to change the method of collecting
motor fuel taxes, moving the point of collection from the
distributor/marketer level to the terminal rank, thereby increasing the
revenue for transportation and education without raising taxes. And, whereas
Mr. Nichols is known as a champion for reducing traffic congestion and
increasing traffic safety through effective management of highway access,
and he was instrumental in developing the nation's first memoranda of
understanding with two rail companies to address rail relocation to areas
outside metropolitan boundaries in Texas, and he has worked diligently to
help create the Texas Rail Relocation and Improvement Fund. And, whereas Mr.
Nichols has shown wisdom in business matters as he has helped lead the
Department through the sale of bonds to finance TXDOT’s first toll road,
State Highway 130, and as he is in the vanguard of those future-oriented
Texans advancing the state’s Trans-Texas Corridor, and as he has devoted his
professional life to improving the quality of life for all Texans. Now,
therefore, be it resolved that the Texas Transportation Commission, on the
occasion of his departure from imminent and active role with the commission,
hereby recognizes and thanks Robert L. Nichols, affectionately known as "El
Nino," for his effective service on behalf of Texas and its citizens.
Presented with pride and gratitude of the Texas Transportation Commission
this the 30th day of June, 2005." And, Commissioner Nichols,
signed by your fellow commissioners and endorsed by all the employees of the
Texas Department of Transportation.
MR. WILLIAMSON: We would normally offer
applause at this time but I have asked you to hold it. We’ve got a few
candid photos that Robert’s wife provided us that show you the real Robert
Nichols. So maybe she didn’t, maybe they were department photos. We’d like
to share them with you.
That’s just sort of a smaller version of
what we will share with the public here in about a month or two when we show
you an appreciation dinner. The way, this is a very unusual situation so we
had to kind of work out the timing of who said what. I normally reserve the
right to speak last but in this case, I think it’s appropriate that we
permit Robert to give his last remarks and then we can, again, thank him for
his service to the state.
I came into the legislature in 1985 with
John Willey and Jack Harris and I think 36 other relatively young and fairly
conservative people, so I’ve been in public service 20 years. I remember
when Governor Perry asked me to retire and take a role in his campaign for
Lieutenant Governor and how difficult it was for me at that time to leave
doing something I truly loved, as Jack and John will remember and as I guess
a current House member or current Senator would affirm, there is no greater
feeling of satisfaction than voluntary, non-professional public service,
particularly in the state that you love. And I know for Robert to leave this
position at this time I know is an emotionally draining time.
Robert seeks other office and I have no
doubt he will be successful so he will be able to apply his public service
talents in a different arena but it is constructive, I think, when I have
control of this forum, to point out that this one great state, from the
booming Republican suburbs of Brazoria to the teeming Democratic suburbs of
Brownsville and Harlingen, from the plains of Amarillo to the hustle and
bustle of East Dallas, from little old Weatherford to El Paso to San Antonio
and all the points in between, we are one great state because men and women
like Robert Nichols lay down their private lives and for virtually no money
come to this capitol and work hard to promote public policy which sometimes
doesn’t make people happy, sometimes makes people mad, but in the end
advances the cause of civilization in our state.
We would not be what we are if it weren’t
for men and women such as Robert. I’ve thought about the remarks I would
want to be in this record when I am long gone and I have decided the best
thing I could say about Robert Nichols is a phrase a close friend of
transportation shared with me just this morning and that is everyone in this
state and particularly the House and Senate members who have watched Robert
work the last eight years recognize that this guy is not a show horse but he
is the absolute best workhorse transportation has ever had and it is with
regret that I watch him leave and it is with joy that I know the entire
state will soon have the benefit of his leadership.
Robert, you may say whatever you wish, the
floor is yours.
MR. NICHOLS: I think I have pretty much
said it. I have truly enjoyed you know the last 8-1/2 years. It’s just been
a great time. I regret that I did not get to every single field office in
the state. I went to all the districts, I kept a list, I had this map and I
had everything marked and whenever I was in an area of the state I would pop
in and I made it to 156 of our field offices, little maintenance, they call
them barns, that a lot of people never go to.
I appreciate all the support the
communities, the industry and the department has helped together to get this
job done and I will truly miss all of you. That’s about it.
MR. WILLIAMSON: We thank all of you very
much for helping us with this. And we're going to take a couple of minute
break. We need to take some pictures. Robert refuses to come back in here
after he leaves. So we're going to take our pictures now. And you're welcome
to coffee, Cokes, the restroom -- whatever you need to do. We'll take us
about five minutes.
(Whereupon, a short recess was taken.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Resume after our brief
recess. At this time I need to approve the minutes of the last meeting --
the meeting of May 26, 2005. Do I have a motion?
MR. HOUGHTON: So moved.
MS. ANDRADE: Second.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I have a motion and a
second. All in favor of the motion signify by saying aye.
(A chorus of ayes.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Opposed, no.
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: The motion's approved.
Minutes -- the motion carries. The minutes are approved.
We seek -- ladies and gentlemen who don't
appear with us every month, we seek to accommodate all special requests for
people who are on a schedule to return back to home. At the request of my
very close friend Kyle Janek the Brazoria County delegation was put at the
first and will be permitted to make their presentation first except another
Senator and a House member who are on even closer schedules than yours have
asked to make their remarks about some items on our agenda. And with your
indulgence I would appreciate it if you would let me recognize first Senator
Seliger, who represents an inner city Houston area. Oh, no. Maybe that's
Amarillo. And, Senator, it's always good to see a friend of transportation
at our podium.
SENATOR SELIGER: Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I appreciate the indulgence of Senator Janek while we talk about the inner
city West Texas.
And, while it was not part of my remarks,
I want to express my great appreciation and admiration for your service to
the people of the state of Texas who have to get around the state of Texas
and must get their wares and services around the state of Texas. I believe
you've had significant impact for the entire state and the people who live
here. And I would like to express my appreciation --
MR. NICHOLS: Thank you.
SENATOR SELIGER: -- of your service. And
while my remarks refer to an agenda item not yet considered, it is my
understanding that there has at this point been a favorable review of the
toll credits that were applied to the Midland and Odessa Transportation
Authority and how important this is and these environmentally very clean
vehicles and the services they will provide the people of this area who, as
do all people in West Texas, greatly depend upon their modes of
transportation -- and all Texans who depend and will depend in the future on
environmentally responsible modes of transportation.
And this will be a program that will be a
substantial success for the people of Midland-Odessa, the Permian Basin, and
the people of the state of Texas, and for this commission.
And I wanted to express my thanks to all
of you and the thanks of the people of Midland-Odessa, Permian Basin, for
your consideration of this most worthy project and for projects around the
state that bode well, I think, for the future of transportation in the state
of Texas.
And Senator Janek will not indulge me for
very long. So I just wanted to say thank you and the best of luck to you,
sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thank you, Senator.
Members, any questions of the Senator?
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: We, again, thank you for
being so aware of the transportation needs of the state. Thank you.
House member Scott Campbell. Are you here,
Scott? (Pause.) Also a publisher and an author of note in my home part of
the state.
REP. CAMPBELL: Mr. Chairman, members.
Thank you for the work you do. I wanted to brag on Commissioner Nichols
before he left, but I'll brag on him anyway. Commissioner Nichols has -- I
know, as all of you do, understand rural issues which are quite a bit
different than some of my colleagues in Dallas and Houston and places.
But Commissioner Nichols visited with me
many times about the need to improve our rural roads. And I know Mr. Behrens
has been out to see us many times, as have most of you.
But we have a little project that has had
some personal -- is a personal project of mine that I have really been
pushing for. And I know the folks at the -- at our district office agree
that we have an intersection -- I think it's listed in your agenda as Loop
306 and FM 388, which is an area near our Goodfellow Air Force Base, which
thankfully we were able to keep open. And those employees use it on a
regular basis, as do our folks that work out at Ethicon.
And it's on the Texas trunk system and
Ports-to-Plains project. But it was slated I think for 10 or 12 years down
the road, and we have been working with the folks out at our district office
trying to figure out a way to get this project moved up.
One of my daughter's friends was killed in
a terrible accident out there right after she had a child. We've had many,
many folks killed and seriously injured. It's a very dangerous intersection
that I travel when we go out to our ranch at Paint Rock.
And I know personally how dangerous it is,
regardless of -- I don't know exactly what criteria you use, but this is
just something that I know we need because of my growing up in our area out
there. And I believe that -- I think Commissioner Nichols and I have had
talks about this many times.
I think -- we're just really asking for
half of the funding from you all. I think our local folks have figured out
how to use their discretionary funding to come up with the rest of the
money.
But it's something we need desperately to
save lives. It's something we need to improve our infrastructure. And I just
ask for your favorable consideration for this project. And we just don't
want to see anybody else killed out there. There are crosses on every corner
already, and we don't need any more out there.
And so we appreciate your consideration of
this and just ask that you keep us in mind. And thanks for everything you do
for the rural folks of Texas and for the rest of the state as well.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Representative Campbell,
we thank you. Are there any questions or dialogue, members? (No response.)
We thank you very much.
The Governor at the beginning of our terms
made it clear that strategic priority money should be focused on partnering
in the state with new initiatives, pass-through tolls. It should be focused
on safety matters and on assisting with retaining our military presence in
the state.
And, certainly, the overpass you speak of
today falls under the safety and the military matter criteria. I would be
surprised if the Commission didn't act favorably later on.
REP. CAMPBELL: I appreciate that. And I'm
about to use some of your good roads to head home in just a minute. So thank
you again for what you do and thanks for allowing me to speak to you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thank you. And we thank
the Brazoria delegation for permitting us to let these two members speak.
Mike?
MR. BEHRENS: I think we'll go to the
delegation.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Very good. Who wants to
take control?
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you, Mr. Chairman,
members, Mr. Director. I want to thank -- I want to take one moment just to
say that we also join you in thanking Commissioner Nichols for the work that
he's done. He's been a great friend, and we will certainly miss him in
Brazoria County. But we'll keep in touch with him I can assure you.
Brazoria County is before you again today
to bring before you our concerns on projects that we feel are important to
Brazoria County, both from the evacuation, from the expansion and growth
that we're having.
First of all, I'd like to, because the
senators are waiting for a bill to come out of committee, allow Senator
Jackson and Senator Janek to speak first. So at this point in time, without
further ado, I'd like to ask Senator Jackson to step forward.
SENATOR JACKSON: Thank you, Judge Willy
and Commissioners, Chairman. I appear before you today -- we were here about
two years ago I think it was -- and were talking about some of the needs of
Brazoria County -- some of the concerns that I had and I still have. And I
know you do as well.
And mainly what's going to happen when we
get a Category 3, Category 4, Category 5 -- hopefully not -- hurricane out
in the Gulf of Mexico and we have to evacuate Houston and the surrounding
area. And it's really going to be a nightmare. And I know our Governor's
come up with a plan. We're working on trying to streamline that.
But there are two areas in Brazoria
County -- there are really two north-south main evacuation routes that we
talked about here a couple of years ago, and that being Highway 36 and that
being Highway 288.
Brazoria County is experiencing a huge
amount of growth. Pearland area in the northern part of the county is one of
the fastest growing areas in the state of Texas.
Highway 288 works very, very well coming
out of the south end of the county until you get up to the Pearland area and
congestion every day of people commuting in and out going into Houston.
That area I think can be streamlined and
work well with some frontage roads and some better access ramps that could
be put there that would make that a whole lot more safe and usable for
people. And we talked about this a couple of years ago.
I think the Commission suggestion to our
delegation at that time was to go back, make some plans, see if you can come
up with some local money -- matching money -- to make these projects work.
And we have done that. I think you'll hear a lot of testimony following me
on a lot more of the details there. We're here. We're ready to go. And we're
ready to see how we can partner and make these projects go as quickly as can
be.
We've been very, very lucky over the last
20 years on storms in the Gulf. And it's not a question of if; it's just
going to be a question of when. It's going to be one of these days we know
we'll have to deal with that.
It was very interesting last night
discussing with Commissioner Houghton on some of the tools that are in the
tool box now to utilize. We talked a little bit about rail and the ability
to take on and put in rail projects. And I'm sure we want to discuss that
further as we go forward and see if there's a potential there.
But we've got in Brazoria County huge
petrochemical investments with some of the major petrochemical complexes
there. The Port of Freeport is growing leaps and bounds. There's a new LNG
facility that's being built down there now. The dirt excavation work is
being performed.
We still have a lot of tourism in the
area. The cities and the growth that they are experiencing is really -- it's
great for the economy. And we just need to make sure that we can do
everything that we can to keep them mobile, as Senator Seliger said a moment
ago. That's kind of the lifeblood of the economy is being able to move your
goods and services from one place to another.
So as we have to leave and go take up a
school finance bill because -- you know, that's a very important element of
our state government, too, to make sure that our kids have a -- have the
best education that they can possibly have. I think the Senate's going to
take this bill up here at ten o'clock. So I'm going to be very, very brief.
But I want to express my appreciation for
the work that you all have done. I know over the last year or so with all of
the e-mails that I've gotten from people in Travis County about toll roads
that you guys have had a long, tough row to hoe in trying to develop policy
and making some things happen in ways that are non-conventional to what's
happened in the past. So --
MR. WILLIAMSON: I saw a quote in the
newspaper today -- this morning about an unrelated topic, but it made me
think of the toll road thing. The guy was quoted as saying, this company had
whipped him into guacamole, and that's kind of how we feel sometimes. We've
been whipped into some smooth cream.
SENATOR JACKSON: Well, I appreciate the
work that you guys and girls do. And I know it's not an easy deal. You have
a whole lot more requests than you have the resources to deal with.
And my message today is that, pursuant to
the advice that the Commission has given our county, we have I think done
our part. We're ready and willing and able to ready to go. So we appreciate.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, questions or
dialogue with Senator Jackson?
MR. HOUGHTON: Senator, I look forward to
working with you. I had a nice visit with you last night about all the
available -- we call it tools in the tool box -- up for your county -- and
not only your county, but counties across the state of Texas to make them
have the competitive edge that we need in this global market and economy
that we are dealing with. And thank you for your support of transportation.
SENATOR JACKSON: Thank all of y'all.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Well, I didn't know when I
was addressing your delegation you were hiding behind one of the bigger
fellows in the front, so I didn't realize you were back there -- that your
constituents need to know that you were as insistent about starting at ten
o'clock as Senator Janek was. And we listen when senators insist.
SENATOR JACKSON: Well, we're going to be
over there voting on a -- I think nearly a 400-page bill. And we've got to
have about five minutes to read it --
MR. WILLIAMSON: Five minutes to look at
it? Yes.
SENATOR JACKSON: Yes -- before we vote.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Things just never change,
do they, Mike?
SENATOR JACKSON: Thank you, Commission.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Good to see you, sir.
JUDGE WILLY: Mr. Chairman, members, I'd
like to ask Senator Janek to come forward, please. Senator?
SENATOR JANEK: Thank you, Judge,
Commissioner, and members. Mr. Chairman and members, I want to thank you. I
tell my three young boys that please and thank you go hand in hand. So,
first, let me say thank you, not just for the global service that you
provide to the people of the state, but for the specifics of what you've
done for the Texas Gulf Coast and southeast Texas.
We had a nasty little brouhaha brewing
along 610 Loop in Texas -- in Houston because it splits the city of
Bellaire. Mr. Trietsch and TxDOT did a tremendous job in dressing up the 610
Loop, putting some aesthetic sound walls and other niceties over there that
made it not only more palatable to the people that live there, but a lot
nicer for the people that use the freeway.
That's one small example of the work that
you do, and I'm grateful for your daily tasks. I don't envy your job, having
to pick amongst so many worthy causes. It's one of the toughest jobs in the
state. I put it up there with little league coaches and school board members
having to say yes or no to so many worthy causes.
The merits of the argument that we're
going to make on behalf of Brazoria County are before you. And they're going
to articulate what their needs are in Brazoria County far better than I can
do.
I would just say this. It is a pleasure to
represent the people of Brazoria County. They're good, hard-working,
hard-playing, God-fearing people down there. I love them. I love campaigning
down there. When they tell you something -- they look you in the eye and
tell you something you can pretty much take it to the bank.
They're a pleasure to represent. They
rarely ask things of me. I try to make these little visits with you as few
and far between as I can. I show up when I think it's important. I'll tell
you what you're going to see with Brazoria County is important for mobility,
for public safety, for the hopefully distant event that we may have
hurricane evacuation needs in that area. It is extremely important.
I'll thank you in advance for your
indulgence that I do need to leave to get back over for House Bill 2. The
House has sent over a wonderful education reform bill. The Senate's going to
see if we can mess it up a little bit.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, any dialogue? (No
response.) Senator -- and I guess Mike's already left. He's not waiting on
me. Oh, no. Both of you have been -- as with Senator Seliger, been stalwart
supporters of the transportation needs of the state. And we appreciate that
more than we can say.
SENATOR JANEK: It's our pleasure.
MR. WILLIAMSON: You all have been good
friends of transportation, and we appreciate it.
SENATOR JANEK: It's our pleasure. Thank
you, Mr. Chairman.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Good to see you, sir.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you, Senator. We
appreciate it very much your being here.
At this time, Mr. Chairman, I'd like to
call on Representative Glenda Dawson.
REP. DAWSON: Thank you, John. Mr.
Chairman, members, I have been asked to speak with you today, not because I
am a Representative, but probably because I taught most of these Brazoria
County people here.
I was a high school teacher for 33 years.
And John Willy and I started transportation needs a long time ago. We went
to school together in Angleton. We rode that big old yellow school bus and
the school driver -- bus driver would say to us, I will drive home whomever
wins this race. So John Willy and I would be put out of the yellow school
bus and we would race. And I'm glad to say that I outraced him every time.
This is called in some cases Brazoria
County and in some cases it's called Brazoria County. And we call it home.
And when I started teaching 36 years ago and taught for 33 years, ladies and
gentlemen, I want you to know in Pearland, Texas, of Brazoria County some of
my students rode horses to school.
We do not ride horses to school in
Pearland any more. We drive cars and we drive lots of cars. And I'm telling
you we are inundated with growth. The news is out. And Brazoria County is
the place to be. And transportation needs have just become overwhelming.
I am delighted to be in this capacity as a
State Representative and to represent such a neat district -- but to be able
to appeal to you sincerely and say, we are in need. We need your help, and
we appreciate all your efforts.
I will close by simply saying with the
group of people we have in leadership in Brazoria County you can depend on
us working in a very ethical, sincere manner. We may not have it all
together, but together we have it all. And I'm telling you we'll work
together and we'll work with you and we thank you sincerely for all the
consideration you might give to us. Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. We
appreciate it.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Oh, thank you. Members?
REP. DAWSON: You're certainly welcome.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thank you, Representative.
REP. DAWSON: You're certainly welcome.
MR. WILLIAMSON: We appreciate it.
REP. DAWSON: Yes, sir.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you, Representative. I
appreciate that. If I may indulge the Commission, Representative Bonnen was
not able to be here. He had a short letter he asked me to read if that's all
right.
It says, Dear Chairman and Commissioners,
I'd sincerely appreciate your consideration of the vital transportation
needs of Brazoria County as presented to you today by the Brazoria County
Economic Development Alliance and my fellow legislators representing this
community.
I offer my full support of the proposed
improvements to State Highway 36 and encourage the Commission to complete
construction funding of State Highway 36 from Freeport to Interstate 10. As
you are aware, the Governor has designated this highway, along with State
Highway 288, as major arteries for hurricane evacuation for the Gulf Coast
region.
Additionally, improvements to State
Highway 36 are imperative to addressing the congestion caused by significant
growth in Brazoria County. By taking these necessary steps to improve
mobility we can achieve a better quality environment for southeast Texas.
Again, thank you for taking the time to
meet with representatives from Brazoria County who are working to increase
awareness of the transportation needs of the county and surrounding
communities.
Please do not hesitate to contact me if I
can be of assistance to expediting the improvements to State Highway 36 and
State Highway 288, which will be of great benefit to the entire region.
Sincerely, Dennis Bonnen, District 25.
If I may give this to the --
MR. WILLIAMSON: Yes, sir.
JUDGE WILLY: I would also like to at this
time recognize one person. We have Commissioner Stavinoha from Fort Bend
County here to show his support for the Highway 36 project coming from and
through Fort Bend County. If you would, please.
COMMISSIONER STAVINOHA: Thank you, Judge,
Commissioners, Mr. Director. Highway 36 splits my precinct in half, starting
at Damon, going through Rosenberg, and going all the way into Wallace
Orchard area.
I've always lived within probably four
miles of Highway 36. At one time when I first got married my driveway was on
Highway 36. Right now I live two miles off of Highway 36. I'm very familiar
with the traffic flow down that corridor.
I dread this weekend. The people from
Brazoria County will be evacuating to go up to the Hill Country to their
deer lease. The people in the Hill Country will be going to their condos on
the beach. And it's going to be impossible to get across Highway 36. I've
noticed this every weekend when there's a holiday the traffic flow back and
forth down 36.
Until 99 gets funded 36 is the corridor
that most people use to get in and out of that area. And right now 99 --
it's in limbo how it's going to be built. But, again, 36 is very important,
not only to Fort Bend County, but certainly to Brazoria Country, and
certainly it needs attention as quickly as possible. Thank you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Wait, wait, wait, wait.
Members, any questions of the Commissioner? (No response.) Oh, okay. Good to
see you again.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you very much. At this
time I would like show just a quick video, if I may, sir.
(Showing of video.)
JUDGE WILLY: Members, in the essence of
time, I'd like to introduce Commissioner Jack Harris at this time and ask
him to step forward.
COMMISSIONER HARRIS: Thank you, Judge. Mr.
Chairman, Commissioners, we thank you so much for you allowing us the time
to be here today.
I would like to quickly go over some of
what we need in regard to Highway 288. You've seen the video presentation.
Let me assure you that our growth is not slowing down in our area. The 2000
census we had 241,000 people -- residents in our county. The estimate now
for -- through 2004 is over 275,000 and growing rapidly.
You heard about the 22,000 platted new
lots that we have in our county ready to be developed. We have another
division -- one subdivision of 11,000 acres that will soon be the home to
150,000 more residents.
This thing is not stopping. We're in an
unusual situation in that we're just south of the Texas Medical Center,
which draws a tremendous number of people to our county to reside. And we're
not that far from NASA. And, as a result, we have a number of people who
live in our county who go over there.
So, obviously, we need help. 288 is
already crowded, as we told you last year. It's gotten worse. It's not going
to get any better.
So, you know, besides hurricanes, as you
saw also, we have to worry about tropical storms. Allison was a tremendous
blow to our area, and it really did stop our ability to move around for
several days. That's going to always be with us, and we understand that.
When you're 40 feet above sea level you've got a problem.
So, anyhow, we'd like to do this first.
We'd like to thank you for helping us begin to build the service road from
2234 to Beltway 8. That's in the process, and we appreciate that. It's going
to help relieve some. But we need to also do from 518 to 2234. Otherwise,
we're going to have a major traffic jam at the Beltway every morning and
every evening. We also need direct connectors from 288 to the Beltway.
The other thing that we need we think
rapidly -- we've already passed a resolution in the Commissioner's Court --
is to take a look and hopefully do something in regard to two lanes either
way in the middle of 288. We think that the traffic now warrants it, and
certainly it will, as I say, only get worse as time goes by. So we'd like
very much for you to look at that with us and let's see if we can't do
either some type of controlled access or whatever is possible in that area.
But we need those four lanes and we need them now.
These projects I'm talking about on 288
will certainly aid our economic growth, and, as you can see, would
definitely protect our citizens in a catastrophe. And that's the thing that
we worry about the most.
So we need your help. We need it now. And
we hope you can help us. Thank you so much.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Questions of former House
member Harris -- Dr. Harris?
COMMISSIONER HARRIS: And, by the way, Mr.
Chairman, I've mentioned to Commissioner Nichols that I was really surprised
that you as a former House member did not tell him how terrible the Senate
is.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you, Commissioner
Harris. One thing that the videos did not show with regard to the evacuation
routes -- first of all, there's two ways out. According to the Governor and
the Department of Emergency Management through the Texas Department of
Public Safety there are two ways out. East of the Brazos you go 288 to the
Beltway and on up to College Station. West of the Brazos Highway 36 to
Brenham -- or did I get that backward. Anyway, that's your two ways out.
But let me show you something that really
brings to heart where we really are on an evacuation situation. The Texas
Department of Public Safety, at the direction of our Governor, asked the
Department of Public Safety to use a scenario that would tell us what would
happen.
What they did they used the 1961 Hurricane
Carla scenario where it was a Cat 4 storm with gusts up to 175, which would
be a Cat 5. And the surge that occurred there created 34 deaths in Brazoria
County and over $400 million in 1961 dollars.
What they did, they moved the hurricane
from the Palacios area as a direct hit. They moved it up to Brazoria County
to do a scenario and show what would happen. Now, what I'm going to show you
does not include the damage from rainfall and flooding such as we received
from Allison.
This is your base coastline map. Note that
the Freeport industrial complex is right in the -- well, won't work on
that -- is right there where it says Coastline Freeport. Then you have your
Chocolate Bayou Plant and industrial complex over at Chocolate Bayou. That's
your Monsanto/Solutia/Equistar/Lyondell. And then, of course, Sweeney is
over to the west.
Here's what happened. Just -- I'm going to
take the categories. A Category 1 storm with a 4.9-foot storm surge will
cause some immediate damage. Note the inlets and the rivers starting to
build.
Now, let's move to a Category 2, which
would cause a 9.9-foot surge. Your petrochemical industry in Chocolate Bayou
is under water. Fortunately, the area in Freeport has a levee that's going
to keep it out of the water for a while longer.
Go to a Cat 3 with a 15.3-foot surge. See,
already you're approaching West Columbia. Lake Jackson is going to be really
suffering. Your plants at Chocolate Bayou are just about under water. Now,
here we have -- where you have two-thirds of the total petrochemical
activity in the United States in this area -- one-third of it's in Brazoria
County. You've just inundated a portion of it.
Now we go to a Cat 4 with 18.8-foot surge.
And you see it's almost up to West Columbia and pushing toward Angleton and
pushing toward Alvin.
Then in a true Cat 5, according to the
Texas Department of Public Safety Emergency Management Office, a 22.4-foot
surge would inundate even the Dow complex and the industrial complex in the
Freeport area. And we have to move these people. That's where we are.
Now, that -- just in that scenario with
Hurricane Carla it was 13,900 people that were affected -- over $3.5 billion
in damages. And this just reinforces the need to try to save lives in the
future.
If we started now it would take four to
five years to get fully ready for a full evacuation in Brazoria County.
That's five years of hurricane seasons or 30 months of sitting and waiting
to see if it's going to happen. Each year we're not hit increases the
probability of a storm for the following year.
In 1998 we were funded for Highway 36. In
2004 -- Highway 36 was scheduled for letting in 2004 for the entire corridor
from Highway 59 to the Port of Freeport. This project was pulled in 2003 and
rescheduled for 2014, except for that portion from Fort Bend to Highway 35.
We came to see you in HGAC -- our Council
of Governments -- and said, Here's our problem. We need help on the State
Highway 288 expansion and the State Highway 36 widening. Two years ago TxDOT
told us we -- what we needed to do, and we came back to make sure we heard
you right. Last year we were told that we had every reason to be successful,
and we appreciate the positive comments.
We took to heart when we were told that
all indications -- we had this right to be successful. We didn't make a
pledge to our voters without input and approval from the MPO and overlaying
our plans on that of TxDOT. We didn't make a pledge to our voters without
the input and positive feedback from TxDOT.
TxDOT and HGAC score their projects on the
basis of regional significance. So I present to you a unanimous resolution
of support from HGAC and our MPO signed by Judge Eckles.
TxDOT and HGAC have scored projects based
on leveraged value. So I present you a check for $50 million on behalf of
the citizens of Brazoria County. With the special districts chipping in I
present you a check for $100 million. I think we've satisfied that leveraged
value.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Hey, if you're in the
Legislature that's one check for $150 million. That's what that is.
JUDGE WILLY: Well, that's why we wouldn't
let the House or Senate have a hold on it. What we're asking for us to move
Highway 36 and Highway 288 expansion into the TIP for 2007 or at the latest
2008 funding cycle. Ideally these funds would -- and I'm hurrying because
I'm running out of time. Ideally these funds could be secured from funds
available through HGAC on the 288 freeway project from Category 2 funds and
evacuation funds for Highway 36. But, if necessary, we're asking you to make
up the difference from your discretionary funds at your control.
Our county and the safety of 276,000
people and our future growth depends on your action. We believe that we've
done our part. We're asking for TxDOT to do its part.
I'd like to have the members of the
Brazoria County delegation stand. Gentlemen? Ladies? These are the people
that represent.
MR. WILLIAMSON: It looks like a --
JUDGE WILLY: And we thank you for letting
us be here.
MR. WILLIAMSON: -- good cross-section.
JUDGE WILLY: And if you have any questions
I'll be happy to answer them, sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: First of all, thank you
for a great presentation. Please be seated. I'm going to have a couple of
questions.
JUDGE WILLY: Okay.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Pretty all-encompassing.
Good presentation all the way around.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Mr. Houghton?
MR. HOUGHTON: The shortfall is -- if
I'm -- my addition is correct, is about 30 million, Mike? Or Amadeo? Who's
in charge here? What's the shortfall --
MR. WILLIAMSON: That would be Gary.
MR. HOUGHTON: Gary?
MR. TRIETSCH: Well, just on Highway 36
it's about $50 to $60 million. And 288 -- that doesn't have any funds. But
to make it -- add four lanes to it is about another $140 million.
MR. HOUGHTON: So we're talking about $200
million?
MR. TRIETSCH: Yes.
MR. HOUGHTON: Give or take?
MR. TRIETSCH: Yes. Give or take.
MR. HOUGHTON: Give or take.
MR. TRIETSCH: On the projects.
MR. HOUGHTON: And, Judge, your
contribution is obviously --
JUDGE WILLY: Obviously, it's $100 million.
We have on the books and planned about $400 million in projects, of which
some of those are totally county projects. We're not even counting those in
the till.
But, just for instance on Highway 36, we
have $10 million that we're willing to hand over right now, you know, for
whatever purpose that Gary needs it. And, believe me, with regard to Gary,
we wouldn't trade him for two speckled puppies. He has been good to us. So
when I fuss at TxDOT I'm not fussing at this guy.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Two speckled puppies.
JUDGE WILLY: He's tried very hard to help
us. But, in answer to your question, we're willing to do whatever you all
wish us to do. We're -- on the expansion of 288 freeway, let us work
together on a pass-through toll. Let us work together with HCTRA -- with
Harris County Toll Road Authority and create a toll road.
I don't care how we do it. There's -- I
know that -- Ric, we talked last night -- or Mr. Commissioner --
MR. WILLIAMSON: No, no. Ric.
JUDGE WILLY: -- talked last night and --
about several ways that we could approach this. There are a lot of ways it
can be done. We just need to think outside the box and get the dang job
done.
MR. WILLIAMSON: And get it done.
JUDGE WILLY: That's it.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Absolutely.
JUDGE WILLY: Now, Highway 36, that's a Cat
2 -- well, it was Cat 4 until somebody changed the designation to Cat 2.
But, you know, that's one that we really need right now. It's already in
the -- it's not in the TIP, but we're at least scheduled for down to 35.
It's that lower part that we need to get done. That's where you're going to
be bringing all those people out.
MR. HOUGHTON: Gary, I'm still confused a
little bit by the number. What's the total project cost -- the total project
cost --
MR. TRIETSCH: Total project cost --
MR. HOUGHTON: -- without the input -- I
mean, the contribution by Brazoria --
MR. TRIETSCH: 120 million on Highway 36.
(Pause.) The total on 36 is roughly 170 million. And we've got about 30
million funded. And that includes the right-of-way cost.
MR. HOUGHTON: Right.
MR. TRIETSCH: That's construction and
right of way.
MR. HOUGHTON: That's everything.
MR. TRIETSCH: Yes.
MR. HOUGHTON: Including the other --
MR. TRIETSCH: Oh, no, that's just State
Highway 36.
MR. HOUGHTON: Okay.
MR. TRIETSCH: 288 -- if my memory is
correct that's 100 to $140 million.
(All talking at once.)
MR. TRIETSCH: Oh, okay. On 36 -- it's in
Fort Bend and Brazoria County. So I'm talking about the whole project.
MR. HOUGHTON: Okay.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Again, thanks.
COMMISSIONER HARRIS: Mr. Chairman, you and
I got elected in 1984. We started serving in 1985. I represented the
southern part of Fort Bend County at that time. 36 went through that area. I
was promised in 1985 that 36 would be taken care of. It's been that long
that road's been sitting there.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Sounds like a familiar
story. Yes, sir.
COMMISSIONER HARRIS: Not unusual.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Hope?
MS. ANDRADE: Judge?
JUDGE WILLY: Yes, ma'am.
MS. ANDRADE: Congratulations. You
certainly -- your community listened to what we said last year, and you've
come back with one solution. You know, this is not the answer to everything
that you need.
But I'm sorry that I missed last night's
event. I got into Austin about 10:30 I think. Our District Engineer failed
to inform me that I-35 had two lanes closed last night, so it took me quite
a bit to get here.
But your community is certainly
progressive in thinking -- innovative in what you've done. And I
congratulate you and I'm extremely proud of what you've done in this short
time.
I think that, you know, the fact that you
mentioned pass-through tolls -- the fact that you mentioned it -- we still
can't get it done as it is now, but we're still willing to sit at the table
all together. And so I'm very committed to supporting and working with you
on this and seeing if we can't resolve the problem that you have out there.
So thank you all so much.
JUDGE WILLY: Thank you very much,
Commissioner. And, like I said before -- and I have said before -- if you
can't get out of the box they're going to bury you in the box. We think
outside the box in Brazoria County and we'll watch other people be buried,
but we want to move forward.
Mr. Chairman, if there's no further
questions may I give you a handout?
MR. WILLIAMSON: Well, I'm going to have
just a couple, John.
JUDGE WILLY: Okay. Certainly.
MR. WILLIAMSON: First of all, I'm just
curious. Who's the predominant electric provider in this part of the state?
Is it --
JUDGE WILLY: You have two providers.
Predominantly, it's Texas/New Mexico Power Company and Reliant -- or the old
Houston Lighting and Power.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Is Reliant also known as
CenterPoint?
JUDGE WILLY: CenterPoint. That's correct.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Okay. And the Legislature
recently extended the TERP program and funded that extension out of some
removals of state highway fund money. Does the TERP program affect you all
directly or just as part of the Houston/Galveston area?
JUDGE WILLY: More the Houston/Galveston
area. I think the program that you're talking about actually was the
expansion of those lines to the south. If that's what you're talking about
that went around Brazoria County through Fort Bend County.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I was curious though. One
of your legislators seemed to be particularly interested in helping
CenterPoint Energy at the cost of the Department. And I was just kind of
curious if there was a reason.
JUDGE WILLY: No. I'm not familiar, nor
have I been advised what the member you're talking about is up to.
MR. WILLIAMSON: No, and we would never
mention that member's name publicly.
JUDGE WILLY: No, sir, we wouldn't.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I've just been curious
about it. You know, when -- one of the most difficult things in dealing with
my former colleagues is to help them understand that every time they take a
dollar out of the department for school buses or every time they cost us an
additional dollar to reimburse utility companies for their right of ways
that is, in fact, a dollar that can't be spent in Brazoria or Harris or
Parker County on a road.
JUDGE WILLY: Mr. Chairman, it's dollars
that --
MR. WILLIAMSON: It's just hard to get
those people --
JUDGE WILLY: It's dollars that we can't
multiply. It's not just one dollar. It's lots of dollars that we can't
multiply when it's used that way.
MR. WILLIAMSON: It's a difficult thing.
Also I would want the new faces in the Brazoria/Fort Bend County area to be
sure that we didn't make a mistake on what we had to do in 2003. I know the
Judge knows about this, but I want all of you to know.
When Mr. Perry became Governor and we were
advising him of the status of the transportation system in the state one of
the things we pointed out to him was the construction plan was overcommitted
across the state.
JUDGE WILLY: Yes, sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: And every year every MPO
and every county judge and every mayor and every business leader was getting
this book -- this happened while you were in Atlanta -- that said, Your
project's in the book. You're promised your project. But when you added up
the cost of all the projects in the book it exceeded our most optimistic
revenues by like 50 percent.
So we were in effect every year -- I don't
mean to say this personally about the department -- we were misleading the
taxpayers of the state into thinking that their projects were going to get
built at some point.
And the Governor didn't want that. He
said, I want you to strip it out and make it honest and we'll just go ahead
and take the hits and everybody will get mad -- and they did -- people got
mad all across the state. But the document's now honest. It's fundable.
I think, Alan, you all did the same
process we did all across the state. You internally through local leaders
decided which projects to move around. And I think that when 36 got taken
back out it was a part of that process and not because we didn't want to
honor our word. And now it's time for us to figure out how to put that back
together, and we're going to try to do that.
I think you made a great presentation. I
think the need is clear. And you know, John, we don't make these decisions
here. But I think you and your community can expect that the Governor is
most interested in addressing your concerns.
JUDGE WILLY: Well, we thank the Governor
and we thank the Commission for allowing us to be here. And anything we can
do to be of help to help create new ways of doing things we're going to be
first in line to be there with you --
MR. WILLIAMSON: Yes.
JUDGE WILLY: -- when you --
MR. WILLIAMSON: Yes, you all are pretty
innovative. Fort Bend County and Brazoria County has been pretty spectacular
over the last few years.
JUDGE WILLY: Well, don't forget old Bart
Sadler up at Montgomery County. He's been pretty good, too.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Well, and they have --
yes, in the last year they've just -- man, they --
JUDGE WILLY: He's getting one of the first
pass-through tolls, so I admire him.
MR. WILLIAMSON: It's good to see you and
Jack again. Thank you. And we're going to take a few minutes and let you all
excuse yourselves. Gary and Alan, thanks for coming up with the bunch. And
take a few moments to stretch and we'll come back in.
(Whereupon, a short recess was taken.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Michael, the agenda's in
your hands.
MR. BEHRENS: Thank you. We're going to
agenda item number 3. That's our aviation minute order for the month on
various airport improvement projects. Dave?
MR. FULTON: Thank you, Mike. For the
record, my name is Dave Fulton, director of the TxDOT Aviation Division.
This minute order contains a request for
grant funding approval for four airport improvement projects. The total
estimated cost of all requests as shown in Exhibit A is approximately $1.4
million, approximately $1.2 million federal and $140,000 in local funding.
A public hearing was held on May 20, 2005.
No comments were received. We would recommend approval of this minute order.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, are there
questions of Dave?
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Do I have a motion?
MR. HOUGHTON: So moved.
MS. ANDRADE: Second.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I have a motion and
second. All in favor of the motion signify by saying aye.
(A chorus of ayes.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: All opposed no.
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Motion carries.
MR. FULTON: Thank you, sir.
MR. BEHRENS: We'll go to agenda item
number 4, which will begin some public transportation agenda items, and the
first being a discussion item to lay before the Commission the distribution
of toll credits and how that program works. Bobby Killebrew.
MR. KILLEBREW: Good morning again.
Commissioners, Mr. Behrens, and Roger. For the record, I'm Bobby Killebrew,
Public Transportation Division interim director.
Today I have the pleasure of leading a
discussion on item 4, criteria for the distribution of toll credits.
(Pause.) I think I -- there it is.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Are we doing --
MR. KILLEBREW: Wrong presentation.
(Pause.) As we're bringing this up I'll go ahead and begin. On June 29,
2000, the Commission authorized using toll credits on transit projects. And
this is by way of a historical recap of what we've done so far as an agency.
The following August history was made in
Texas with the first award of toll credits for a transit project. Hill
Country Transit District, operating a small organized system, serving the
areas of Killeen, Copperas Cove, and Harker Heights, received a toll credit
award for the procurement of transit capital for that new system.
In November 2003 the most recent award of
toll credits for transit projects was made to Beaumont and Port Arthur for
vehicle procurement.
And on February 24, 2005, the Commission
indicated their intention to make toll credits available for the JARC --
that's Job Access Reverse Commute -- Colonias Project, which TxDOT is in the
process now of issuing an RFP for project proposals.
The past toll credit awards for transit
projects to date total approximately 27 million. The amount of power and
innovative financing has or will allow the leveraging of is almost $108
million in federal funds to carry out over 300 transit projects.
Projects benefitting from the use of toll
credits range from buses in Killeen, Mesquite, Victoria, Beaumont, Port
Arthur, and others, facilities in Lubbock, Longview, Bryan/College Station,
and Waco, rail projects in Dallas and Galveston, as well as
TxDOT-administered grants which assist nonprofits, rural, and small urban
transit systems and the elderly and disabled program and the rural program
and in our vehicle capital replacement program.
The Texas Transit Association and the
Department have both conducted various surveys over the past several months.
A quick review of the survey results for projects where systems have
indicated the lapse of their federal funds due to their inability to provide
match, and thus the need for toll credits, are in fiscal year '05. We have
one system that is scheduled to have a federal grant lapse because of their
inability to match.
MR. WILLIAMSON: And what's that system?
MR. KILLEBREW: That system is
Midland/Odessa.
MR. WILLIAMSON: And will that be put in
local funds -- if we were to approve toll credits today would they be put in
local funds with that?
MR. KILLEBREW: Commissioner, I believe
there's some representatives from that system here today that would like to
speak on that subject regarding their local match ability.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Okay.
MR. KILLEBREW: In fiscal year '06 we
have -- found out through the survey that there will be seven systems that
will have grants that will lapse because of their inability to match, and
they're also requesting toll credits.
Likewise, in fiscal year '07 there's an
additional four systems that will have grants that will lapse at that time.
The projects funded with federal funds
identified in this table include vehicle replacements, new vehicle fleet
expansion, facility construction for maintenance and administrative
operations, and facility renovations.
Presented for discussion matters today is
a process which involves an annual call for projects. As the points outlined
in the discussion are tied to elements which may not currently exist, the
approach is phased so that in the short term projects can be considered
using criteria applicable for today, and in the long term using criteria
which is currently being developed.
And before you now is a table that lists
some criteria -- some screening criteria that the Department might consider
in addressing proposals in the short term versus the long term. And I'll
just go through this table quickly.
The first item in good standing. Currently
in the Texas Administrative Code in the public transportation area there is
a definition for good standing. And it's recommended that the same be
applied to toll credits. And that particular definition reads, A status
indicating that the department's Director of Public Transportation has not
sent a letter to an entity signifying the entity is in noncompliance with
any aspect of a program.
Application as the oversight agency, the
Department should be involved from the get-go. Systems which intend to use
toll credits should involve the department very early in the process,
specifically if these plans are requesting and securing federal earmarks for
which the system plans to request toll credits in lieu of local match for
funds.
The Federal Transit Administration
requires systems to identify at the time of application what their match
rate's going to be. Once a system files an application with the Federal
Transit Administration they lock in a match ratio. So if a system indicates
to FTA we're going to use local funds as the match, a match ratio is locked
in. They can't come back after the fact and apply toll credits retroactive
and has to be there from the get-go.
Regional endorsement -- as the Department
moves forward with regional service planning transit projects should be
linked to the local service plan. Until such plans are formalized it's
recommended that the regional service planning partners confirm support for
the projects.
ITS Projects -- projects falling under the
ITS must conform to regional architecture plans as a federal requirement.
Improvements to service delivery and also
the business plan -- as short-term criteria transit system would allow the
improvement -- excuse me -- as a short-term criteria transit systems would
outline the improvement to service delivery. As the department develops and
adopts a business plan it's recommended that the transit system -- or that
the system detail -- how the project will support or carry out the business
plan.
And local contribution -- toll credits are
recognized by the Federal Transit Administration as an innovative financing
tool. As such, it is recommended that the request assure that the use of
toll credits will not decrease overall local funds.
Evaluating the project -- the criteria
outlined in this table -- an attainment plan. As provided by
House Bill 3588
the department is charged with furthering the state's efforts to reduce air
pollution.
Performance and efficiencies -- also
provided by House Bill 3588. The legislation speaks to eliminating waste and
the provision of public transportation services and generating efficiencies
that will permit increased levels of service.
Other Health and Human Service programs
and Workforce Commission programs -- as TxDOT's public transportation role
has evolved and continues evolving so much the project's funded through the
department. Projects should be considered if they can exist and provide
benefits outside of the traditional silo programs.
Coordination -- the importance of having a
coordinated project, one that will share transportation resources,
responsibilities, and activities of various agencies with each for the
overall benefit of their community.
As a matter of process, department staff
could screen and evaluate projects considering and discussing the requested
project's potential benefit to the public -- Texas public transportation
system. Each project could be evaluated using the aforementioned criteria as
a measure of the quality of the project. Those projects meeting or exceeding
an appropriate level or quality could be considered by the commission
contingent on the availability of toll credits and other commission
priorities.
And, with that, I'll end the discussion
and I can answer any questions.
MR. WILLIAMSON: First of all, Bobby, I
want to thank you for distilling a complex discussion item to the bullet
points the commission needs to focus on.
Members, we do have one person wishing to
offer comment in this discussion item. Would you like to question Bobby now
or would you prefer to --
MR. HOUGHTON: I'll wait to hear.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Okay. Well, if you'll just
sit down for a second, Bobby. We'll hear from Glenn Gadbois. (Pause.) I
think -- don't you represent the AGC?
MR. GADBOIS: Exactly. How did you know?
Commissioners, Chairman, my name is Glenn Gadbois, and I'm with the Just
Transportation Alliance. And we look forward to that time where we will have
as good a working partnership with AGC as we apparently have with the
department.
As you will notice -- let me just pass
these out. (Pause.) Notice, with some conversations with Bobby with PTN
-- Killebrew -- and Steve Simmons and Michael Morris and some of the public
transportation providers, we have come to much the same conclusion -- or at
least same recommendation -- that Bobby has.
Although we want to encourage you to
expand out the conversation or at least in terms of thinking about the use
of toll credits to expand that to their full application.
What we have done here -- because toll
credits are going to become -- we have absolute faith that things are going
to fall into place such that toll credits will become in the future one of
Texas' more valuable tools in terms of getting all sorts of transportation
projects done.
As a consequence we encourage you not to
think just about transit when you're thinking about how you implement your
rules or how you consider investing toll credits either in the short term or
the long term.
As a consequence I ask your indulgence for
a moment. I know we e-mailed these to you, but what I'm going to do is just
kind of walk you through the highlights of some concepts here that I think
are worth noting and thinking about as you move forward.
The first is that toll credits are a
valuable investment tool for a number of different kinds of transportation.
Those who do rail are very excited and enthusiastic about toll credits. And
that could draw down many more toll credits than the state has available
right now in terms of the projects that are moving forward.
As we look to the future and the passage
of a constitutional referendum and the development of plans and the
implement of the rail relocation and improvement program -- or whatever
that's going to be called -- as we look forward to regional public
transportation planning and how that evolves toll credits will become even
more valuable.
As a consequence -- and then I guess we
also have in place for now a couple of years -- and certainly evolving,
maturing, developing is the Texas Metropolitan Mobility Plan. I think on all
of those fronts toll credits will become more and more valuable as the
department has more of them and those become more regularly available.
As a consequence what I proposed here is
thinking about those different categories of places to invest. And then
looking both in the short term and the long term to encourage a structure
that promotes or has people coming to you in the way that you want.
As a consequence -- and I'm not tied to
these percentages -- I mean, basically, they're kind of rough guesses. I'm
not sure anybody -- but I certainly don't know what good percentages for
each one of these categories would be in actual fact.
But what I tried to do is develop a
structure that showed you, if you invest some in the Texas Metropolitan
Mobility Plan in the short term, if you invest some in regional planning
and/or transit in small urban in the short term, if you invest some in rail
relocation in the short term -- what that does is -- what that is likely to
do is to encourage people to work together if they need more money than is
in that category.
Or, if they're smart and playing well,
then that will encourage those transit folks or those rail folks that are in
the metropolitan area to apply to this commission for both.
We have also created a category for
commission strategic funding because we think it is in important, especially
over the short term, that the commission maintain some -- or as much
flexibility as is possible.
As this evolves out, however, and you get
the rail plan in place, as you get the regional service planning, for which
you have worked so hard, Commissioner, in place, then that will allow us to
move from kind of competitive allocations statewide, which are never as
strategic, to a strategy of supporting and implementing the plans that these
local folks have worked on so hard, in which case you could consider where
those plans make sense allocating regionally, in which case, if you will
notice on that box on the first page, the long term -- the Texas
Metropolitan Mobility Plan category goes way up because what we have done is
recognized that there will be needs for rail and there will be need for
transit and there will be need for implementation of the Texas Metropolitan
Mobility Plan that could all be allocated in one bundle to those regions.
There will also, however, be rail outside
of that. There will be transit outside of that. The regional plans outside
of that still retain some percentage.
That's the basic layout of the structure
that we think -- well, we want to encourage you to think about because we
think, much like our political system, that will encourage people to work
together and not simply come to the State with their own individual or
singular project and concerns.
We do completely agree with what you heard
from the department on the idea of making sure you're clear on some up-front
eligibility. When this department has done other competitive processes --
and I'll name one -- the enhancement program -- and that wasn't clear in the
front end you have all sorts of problems on the back end that I think the
department is well aware of now. And I'm sure, you know, when you put out
that competitive process you'll make sure that, you know, there's clear
enough guidance on the front end.
But to the extent that you can articulate
we want you working together. We want to make sure that there is a
maintenance of effort in terms of local contribution. We want to make sure
those things are in place that will help you in the long run.
The only other thing that I'd like to
mention about this is that our assumptions on this are really, you know,
made out as clearly and in bullet point fashion as we can make it. We still
need to pass a federal transportation bill that brings Texas more toll
credits. And we still encourage, because we have been encouraged, to make
sure everybody in this room understands how important it is to articulate
that that still needs to happen when this bill occurs -- and this bill needs
to occur quickly.
The -- you know, that the planning has to
evolve and get in place for both the rail and for the regional public
transit. But we do encourage you as these assumptions start falling in
place. That will allow you to evolve this, that will allow you to
sub-allocate, which we encourage you to think of as a much more strategic
investment than simply doing statewide competitive granting.
That's the short remarks on this. If there
are any questions I will -- or things that I passed over that you saw and
didn't understand, I'll be more than happy to answer them. Otherwise, I'll
let you get on with your busy agenda.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Questions, members?
MR. HOUGHTON: So you're -- I have a
question. Where's Bobby? Bobby, what's our balance as far as toll credits
are today?
MR. KILLEBREW: I had to ask the almighty
guru of the finance division that question yesterday. And the answer I got
back was 114 million.
MR. HOUGHTON: $114 million. And we could
suck all that up in one or two projects. Correct?
MR. KILLEBREW: If the project were
substantial they could go quickly.
MR. HOUGHTON: Quickly. Okay. You did --
you talked about -- and correct me if I say this wrong -- diminished local
match. So we want the locals to have -- is what you're talking about is
blood in the game. Correct? I call it that.
MR. KILLEBREW: Yes, sir. What I was
referring to that there is -- I don't know if it's tempting to do this, but
if you get something such as toll credits, which would supplant your local
match, that local match could go away -- could go for something else, say,
in the city government -- could go for public works, it could go for
sidewalks, play parks, whatever.
What we are advocating that we'd like to
see is that, if it's not using this to match this capital that that
investment remains in the transit program for operating, for --
MR. HOUGHTON: As a requirement? Can we
require that?
MR. KILLEBREW: I'd have to ask legal
counsel if that could be a requirement we could put in on the system or not,
sir.
MR. HOUGHTON: See, the fear I have is we
have these toll credits but we do not require that match. I mean, they take
the money and put it into general revenue and it goes into parks. Can we
require that -- I call it displacement. We're displacing dollars somewhere
else. It's a movement of money.
MR. KILLEBREW: Speaking, not as a lawyer
but as a contractual thing, I would think we could probably write something
to the contract saying, you know, our understanding is these toll credits
are going to free up local match, which we contractually want you to agree
that you'll keep in the program.
MR. GADBOIS: The federal rules on toll
credits already require maintenance of effort in terms of assessing the toll
credits. And all we're now looking at is -- or suggesting I think is that
the department look at making sure people don't go backwards in their
investment in transit because they're getting this investment that should be
a short-term help to fix a problem. It should never be a long-term
substitution for the overall investment in transit.
MR. HOUGHTON: Okay.
MS. ANDRADE: Bobby, if we can't require it
can we strongly encourage it?
MR. KILLEBREW: Yes, ma'am, I think we
should be able to do that.
MS. ANDRADE: Okay. Because, you know, my
fear is that, like Ted says, 114 million, you know, will go soon. So we can
strongly encourage that any application would be seriously considered if
local contribution came along with it.
Now, when you're establishing this
criteria are we thinking we're going to award these toll credits at a
certain period every year or are we going to take application for requests?
I mean, how are you envisioning that we're going to do this?
MR. KILLEBREW: What I laid out this
morning was on the lines of an annual call for projects --
MS. ANDRADE: Okay. And I --
MR. KILLEBREW: -- that we kind of
annualize this process or semi-annualize this process so we're not doing
these every other week -- having people plan ahead.
MR. WILLIAMSON: So what we might do --
what you might recommend is we have a call for maybe 75 percent of -- in
other words, we might announce based on last year's activity we have
available this year 200 million -- the commission has authorized the
department to distribute these credits two-thirds or three-quarters based on
this call -- the balance they would reserve much as they reserve the
strategic priority funds for emergency cases. That would be an acceptable
approach.
MR. KILLEBREW: Yes, sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thank you. And what I hear
you saying, Glenn, is the department's recommendations are okay, but don't
stop there -- blend it into the regional service planning concept we're
trying to implement on transportation across the state.
MR. GADBOIS: Yes, sir. And the other
things that we obviously know are coming down the pipe -- the rail
improvement, for example.
MR. WILLIAMSON: So, in effect, let Alan
Clark and Michael Morris have some authority to figure out how to use these
as they would any other tool in the toolbox to address transportation issues
in their area.
MR. GADBOIS: In the short term I think
that you have -- I encourage you to think about rewarding them -- those who
have gone through great struggle to try to implement the Texas Mobility Plan
because they then could come back and say, See, it is already rewarding us
to have done this. And in some places that has been a terrible struggle, as
I'm sure you are aware.
But then as things evolve, yes, I think
that -- I would hope that you would have more and more confidence in that
planning process -- regional transit plans and rail plans in the mobility
plan such that where that's possible you can wrap them together and allocate
to -- one allocation to the whole bunch.
MR. HOUGHTON: Yes. Alan -- and the thing
that might piggyback the Chairman's remarks is, as long as we're not
displacing dollars into general revenue to go to some other thing other than
non-transit issues -- transportation issues, whether it's roads, TM -- the
mobility fund.
If we can put that in some type of
contract form -- that we can see it and track it, that it's not going over
here to sidewalks, then I'm for it. But, other than that, then I wouldn't be
for it.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Bobby.
MR. KILLEBREW: If I can clarify just a
couple of remarks, if I may. One, for Commissioner Andrade, what we find
most often in systems, in order to match capital they end up taking out of
their operating budget, which means that's fewer rides that they provide
because they have to buy a new vehicle because the old vehicle wore out. So,
you know, right now they're playing that little shell game. So that's a
good -- this is a good assistance to help keep their shell game from
happening.
And, in regards, Chairman, to the -- say,
an annual call for projects, typically FDA has a -- they produce annually in
the Federal Register their annual apportionments.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Uh-huh.
MR. KILLEBREW: So there's kind of a place
and a time line that most of the money is probably known and that cycle
would have to coincide with that.
MR. WILLIAMSON: You think you've got
enough reaction from commission members to begin to develop a more concrete
recommendation?
MR. KILLEBREW: I believe so.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I think, unless I hear
objection, colleagues, we'll ask him to go ahead and start preparing some
criteria for our consideration.
MR. BEHRENS: We will move forward with
that.
MR. WILLIAMSON: With some teeth.
MR. BEHRENS: We'll move forward with that.
Yes, sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thank you, Bobby.
MR. BEHRENS: Bobby, if you would, we'll go
to your agenda item number 5. And if you would present those proposed minute
orders.
MR. KILLEBREW: Again, for the record, I'm
Bobby Killebrew, Public Transportation Division interim director. As follow
up to our previous discussion, before you for your consideration is a minute
order which awards toll credits to the Midland-Odessa Urban Transit
District.
The Transit District responded to TxDOT in
a recent survey that they expect to lose $983,679 in a federal earmark for
four alternatively-fueled buses planned for their fleet expansion.
Midland-Odessa is requesting 201,476 in
toll credits. The Federal Transit Administration has issued a letter to
Midland-Odessa Urban Transit District stating that their application for
funds must be submitted by June 2005. And if my calendar is correct today's
the last day of June 2005. And failure to submit a timely application will
cause their earmark to lapse on September 30, 2005.
In light of the difficulty in securing a
federal earmark and the local impact these federal funds have for the
Midland-Odessa area staff does recommend approval for this minute order.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, we have a couple
of witnesses. Do you wish to hear from witnesses first?
MS. ANDRADE: Please.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I always pick wrong, so
who goes first, Ken or Bill? Ken. Ken Smithson.
MR. SMITHSON: Good morning, Mr. Chairman,
members of the Commission. It's a privilege to be here today. And we've
enjoyed working with you and -- including Commissioner Nichols on transit
projects over the years.
My name is Ken Smithson for the record.
I'm the general manager of Easy Rider in Midland-Odessa. I'm also on the
board of directors for the Texas Transit Association.
On behalf of the board I'd like to thank
you for considering the use of toll credits for transit capital projects
that will serve to sustain and grow public transportation across the state.
This will not only help transit projects in the large cities where the
majority of toll credits are generated, but also the small urban and rural
areas of the state where operating funds are already in short supply.
Midland-Odessa is just one example of the
latter. And we appreciate being on the agenda today for consideration. As
you know, Easy Rider has enjoyed outstanding success as a new start transit
system in the state -- just under two years in service now. And we can
hardly keep up with the growth. We're experiencing 36 percent increase in
fixed route ridership over our first year.
On our paratransit service our ridership
has increased by almost 200 percent. That's the type of public
transportation that hasn't been seen in West Texas in a long time.
Public transportation and health and human
services have long coordinated their services in West Texas. And Easy Rider
has quickly folded into those efforts. We have a seat at the table of a 5310
advisory committee, so we sit with the rural provider, the elderly and
disabled transportation provider, and other providers in the area. And we
plan programs for the elderly and disabled transportation service.
MHMR in both cities has been able to put a
lot of their clients on our buses instead of transporting them in their
small vans. One agency in one of the cities that serves seniors was able to
not purchase more vehicles because there's now public transportation and
those seniors are using our service.
And we've hooked up with a regional 2-1-1
center so that the people have one number to call for transportation
information, including ours. We're providing summer bus service for kids to
the Boys and Girls Club. And Workforce Network has -- instead of handing out
cash to their job seekers, are now buying bus passes and tickets and putting
their folks on our service as well.
And we anticipate that Easy Rider will be
one of the -- at least one of the lead agencies in regional service
planning. And our goals are to optimize coordination and provide for
seamless service amongst the transportation providers in our area.
So, for these reasons and more, we believe
that Midland-Odessa is a prime candidate for toll credits at this time so
that we can purchase more vehicles to keep the system growing. One way of
using those vehicles that we've talked about locally is even providing some
type of intercity service between the two cities which are separated by 20
miles. There's a lot of people that need to commute back and forth, and
that's one idea that we had for using these vehicles.
So we think the project will serve well --
and not just the citizens of West Texas, but the interest of public
transportation across the state. And we appreciate your consideration.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Questions of this witness,
members?
MR. HOUGHTON: Yes. I'll go back to what
I -- the thing with Bobby. If you're experiencing the growth is it my
understanding -- are you coming up with a dollar match or are you going to
use the toll credits as your match?
MR. SMITHSON: We'd like to use the toll
credits for the match on this particular project. But to comment on your
earlier question, the two cities are not reducing any contribution toward
this project. In fact, both -- the two cities combined have contributed more
to public transportation than the state has, including fiscal year '05.
As an example, the state provided
$307,000; the two cities provided $339,000. And that's not even counting the
fare box revenue and other locally generated revenues. So they're not
reducing their contribution, but they've intended to keep it at the same
level. And that goes toward operating.
MR. HOUGHTON: That answers my question.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Okay. Thank you, Ken.
MR. SMITHSON: Thank you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Bill Dingus?
MR. DINGUS: Yes. My name is Bill Dingus.
Thank you, Commissioners. I'm a City Councilman at large in Midland. And
as -- so I'll be talking from the Midland perspective. But, of course, we're
talking about Midland-Odessa.
And I came down specifically for two
reasons today. One is I can't think of a better way to say thank you for
helping us start this bus system than coming here personally to tell you
that. I do not think we'd have it today -- I know we wouldn't have it if it
weren't for federal funds, and I don't think we'd have it without the state
funds we've received, not just because of the value of the money, but
because it shows that at the state level and at the federal level there is a
recognition of the importance of public transportation. And I think that
additional funds would enhance that message from the state.
But I want to give you a little history
about why Midland has a very young bus system. There are those in Midland
who don't like the bus system. They're not the riders of the bus system. And
when we -- when I was pushing for this -- I ran for mayor and lost, in part
because I was a big proponent of public transportation, which we did not
have at the time. And later I spent a lot of political capital and we got it
in. I'm proud of that.
But there are people who said it will
never work. It's going to fail. It's -- people aren't going to ride these
buses. You just don't understand Midland. And I was afraid that might be the
case. And I watched buses every time they went by, counting heads in those
buses. And was I relieved that it has been a success.
I want to thank Ken Smithson, who just
talked here. It's partly due to his oversight of this project. But, also, he
did a very savvy thing. He was very conservative in his numbers. He told us
he thought it'd cost Midland -- not Midland-Odessa -- but Midland about a
quarter of a million dollars a year in local monies. It's cost us about
225-. And so it hasn't cost us quite as much as we thought. The ridership is
above what we thought it would be.
I think it's a huge success. I'm very
proud of it. And it really benefits the people of Midland, who don't have a
lot of political clout.
However, just recently we had this
discussion about buying new buses and it came up again -- you know, how is
it working --
MR. WILLIAMSON: They must have some
political clout. They elected you.
MR. DINGUS: Thank you. And I'm here for
them today. But there are people who don't listen to them as vehemently as
other people who say, Well, who's riding these buses. And I won't go into
it.
I just want you to understand that the
people in West Texas need these buses. And every encouragement we can get
from the State makes it that much easier to maintain it.
I think in another five years this will
become a fabric of the community and it won't be at the risk it is now of
going away. It's still new and people are saying how valuable is it. It's
extremely valuable.
And I think in, like I say, five years
it's going to be part of Midland and won't be in any danger at all. But
right now it's -- I wouldn't say it's treading on thin ice, but any type of
encouragement we could get from the State would be greatly appreciated. And
I thank you for your time.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Questions of this witness,
members?
MS. ANDRADE: Thank you for what you do for
public transportation. It's great to have you as a champion there.
MR. DINGUS: Thank you.
MS. ANDRADE: And I certainly would support
this. Thank you.
MR. DINGUS: Good deal.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thanks for your courage in
stepping out there.
MR. DINGUS: Another reason I came today is
because I can't expect Ken to say these things. He's always supposed to be
upbeat --
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thanks for your courage.
MR. DINGUS: -- about everything.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Thanks for stepping out
there.
MR. DINGUS: Thank you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Because it's important to
the State of Texas and the people of the state to move them around.
MR. DINGUS: Thank you very much.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Did you want to say
something? (Pause.) You had a question on your face so I thought maybe you
had --
MR. JOHNSTON: Oh, no --
MR. WILLIAMSON: -- you might be one of
those guys that didn't like the bus.
MR. JOHNSTON: I didn't sign up to speak,
but I'm certainly here to answer any questions. But in -- I'm Marcus
Johnston, assistant city manager for the City of Midland.
And, certainly, we -- as a city we do
support public transit. It's been very successful. We are continuing our
commitment to supporting public transportation. We're keeping our level of
funding level from the current year to next year. And we certainly
appreciate your concerns that funds are not diverted to other uses. We're
keeping our money in public transit and we appreciate your support. And I
thank you very much for your consideration.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Questions of this witness,
members?
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Fill a card out for us, if
you would.
MR. JOHNSTON: Sure. Will do. Thank you.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Okay. Members, you've
heard the presentation by our staff. You've heard the witnesses' testimony.
Do I have a motion?
MS. ANDRADE: So moved.
MR. HOUGHTON: Second.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I have a motion and a
second. All those in favor of the motion signify by saying aye.
(A chorus of ayes.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: All opposed no.
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Motion carries.
MR. BEHRENS: Okay. Bobby, if you would,
continue with agenda item 5(b).
MR. KILLEBREW: Again, for the record, I'm
Bobby Killebrew, Public Transportation Division interim director. For your
consideration this morning a minute order which provides the state
funding -- state formula funding for small urban and rural transportation
systems for fiscal year 2006.
This minute order would allocate state
funds of 28,741,068. These funds have been allocated according to the
formula approved by the Commission on May 26. According to the formula
10,059,374 has been allocated among 30 small urban providers and 18,681,694
has been allocated among 39 rural providers.
I'd like to highlight some recent changes
in the rural provider community. San Patricio Community Action Agency
dissolved itself as a rural transit district effective November 8, 2004, and
San Patricio County now receives transit services from Rural Economic
Assistance League.
Fort Bend County established itself as a
rural transit district in accordance with Chapter 458 of the Texas
Transportation Code effective May 24, 2005.
And, finally, effective September 1, 2005,
Rockwall County will change its affiliation from Hunt County Committee on
Aging to Kaufman Area Rural Transportation.
Your consideration and approval of this
minute order would be appreciated.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Do you have witnesses?
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, we have no
witnesses. You've heard the staff explanation and recommendation. Do I have
a motion?
MS. ANDRADE: So moved.
MR. HOUGHTON: Second.
MR. WILLIAMSON: I have a motion and a
second. All those in favor of the motion signify by saying aye.
(A chorus of ayes.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: All opposed no.
(No response.)
MR. WILLIAMSON: Motion carries.
MR. BEHRENS: Continue, Bobby.
MR. KILLEBREW: Continuing, Commissioners,
with the next item, for your consideration this morning is a minute order
which approves funding for intercity bus transportation in Texas.
By regulation 15 percent of the 5311 rural
federal funds are to be set aside to enhance and improve intercity bus
service unless the Governor certifies that intercity service is adequate in
the state.
The projects recommended for approval were
selected based on responses to a request for proposal issued on February 11
of this year. Twenty-three proposals were received requesting $2.7 million
for operating, facility construction and renovation, vehicle lifts, computer
software and hardware, and planning.
The proposals were reviewed based on their
technical merits and the projects and the quality of the entity. Fifteen
projects are recommended and are listed in Exhibit A in alphabetical order
by the project sponsor.
The well-publicized closures of intercity
bus routes across the United States, including Texas, have highlighted the
critical need for this service. The amount requested for immediate
commencement is in Category A -- is from the combination of unobligated
amounts from previous years and the available appropriations from fiscal
year 2005 totaling $726,983.
Projects listed in Category B would be
funded with the expected balance of fiscal year '05 funds totaling $821,061.
And the project listed in Category C
represents a multi-year project and would be financed with future
appropriations totaling $249,747. A total for all categories is a little bit
under 1.8 million.
Your consideration and approval of this
minute order would be appreciated.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Are there witnesses, Mike?
MR. BEHRENS: No, sir.
MR. WILLIAMSON: Members, there are no
witnesses. You heard the staff recommendation -- explanation and
recomm |